
CommercialBy Mike Giordano Jr. | MGG Team, Coldwell Banker Realty | Winter Park, FL
An Orlando investment property can look great in a listing flyer and still be a bad deal. The asking price, the photos, and the “pro forma” numbers are the seller’s story. Your job as a buyer is to check that story against the real income, the real expenses, and the real condition of the building.
This guide walks through how I look at a commercial investment property in Orlando and the surrounding counties: the numbers, the documents, the property itself, and the signals that tell you to walk away. It isn’t tax or legal advice, so bring your CPA and attorney in early.
Key takeaways
- Judge a deal on actual trailing-12-month income and expenses, not the pro forma.
- The rent roll, leases, and deposits should all tell the same story.
- Don't assume your taxes and insurance will match the seller's bills.
Start With What You Want the Property to Do
Before you compare deals, decide what the money is for. A retail strip center, a small warehouse, an office building, and a 5+ unit apartment building all behave differently. Ask yourself:
- Income now or growth later? A fully leased building with long leases pays steady income. A half-empty building may cost less but needs leasing work.
- How hands-on do you want to be? Multi-tenant retail and office need more management than a single-tenant industrial building.
- Will you use part of it yourself? Many business owners buy a building, occupy part of it, and lease the rest.
- How long will you hold it? Your hold period changes how much a roof, HVAC, or parking lot replacement matters.
Across Orange, Seminole, Osceola, Lake, and Brevard counties, the same property type can perform very differently from one corridor to the next, so the “why” should narrow the “where.”
The Numbers: NOI and Cap Rate in Plain English
Net operating income (NOI) is the rent the property collects, minus the costs of running it (taxes, insurance, repairs, management, utilities the owner pays). It does not include your mortgage payment.
Cap rate is NOI divided by the price. It tells you what the property earns on the purchase price before financing.
Illustration only, not a market figure: a building priced at $1,000,000 with $70,000 of NOI is a 7% cap rate. If that same NOI is really $55,000 once you fix the seller’s expense numbers, the cap rate drops to 5.5% at the same price. That gap is why the next sections matter.
Three things to watch:
- Actual vs pro forma. Ask for the trailing 12 months of real income and expenses, not just the projected numbers.
- Missing expenses. Management, reserves for replacements, and vacancy are often left out of a seller’s numbers. Add them back in.
- Taxes and insurance after you buy. Don’t assume your costs will match the seller’s bills. Ask your CPA to estimate property taxes based on your purchase, and get insurance quotes for your ownership.
Read the Rent Roll and the Leases
The rent roll lists every tenant, their rent, and their lease dates. It’s the fastest way to see whether the income is solid. I covered the details in how to analyze a rent roll, but the short version is:
- Check when leases expire. Several leases ending in the same year is a risk.
- Compare each tenant’s rent to the rest of the building and the area.
- Match the rent roll to the actual leases and to bank deposits during due diligence.
- Read who pays what. In a triple net (NNN) lease the tenant pays taxes, insurance, and maintenance. In a gross lease the owner does. The same rent means very different NOI.
- Ask for tenant estoppel certificates, where each tenant confirms their rent, deposits, and any disputes in writing.
For apartment buildings with five or more units, see is this multifamily deal a good investment.
Check the Property, Not Just the Paperwork
- Zoning and use. Confirm with the city or county that the current use, and any use you plan, is allowed. Orlando, Winter Park, and the unincorporated county areas each have their own rules.
- Building systems. Roof, HVAC, electrical, plumbing, and fire safety. Get a commercial inspection and ask for the age of each major system.
- Environmental. A Phase I environmental site assessment is standard for many commercial purchases and often required by lenders, especially for properties with past automotive, dry cleaning, or industrial use.
- Parking, access, and visibility. For retail and service tenants, these drive rent and vacancy.
- Survey and title. Look for easements, encroachments, and recorded restrictions.
When the Property Comes With a Business
Some Orlando investment properties are sold together with the business that operates there. In that case you’re buying two things: the real estate, valued on its own, and the business, valued on its earnings. Keep them separate in your analysis, and make sure the rent the business could pay a landlord is realistic. I wrote more about this in selling a business with its real estate in Orlando.
Signs It’s Time to Walk Away
- The seller won’t provide actual income and expense records.
- The rent roll doesn’t match the leases or the deposits.
- Big repairs are coming and the price doesn’t reflect them.
- The use you need isn’t allowed, or needs approvals you may not get.
- The deal only works if everything goes right.
Walking away from the wrong building is part of buying the right one.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is a good cap rate for an Orlando investment property?
It depends on the property type, location, tenant quality, and lease terms, and it moves with interest rates. Rather than chasing a number, compare the cap rate to similar recent sales and to your financing cost, and make sure the NOI behind it is real.
What documents should I ask for before buying?
At minimum: a current rent roll, all leases and amendments, trailing 12 months of income and expenses, recent tax and insurance bills, service contracts, and any past inspection or environmental reports.
Can I buy commercial property in Orlando and use part of it for my own business?
Yes. Owner-occupied buildings are common. The financing, zoning, and how you value the leased portion all change, so plan for them from the start.
Do I need a CPA or attorney?
We always recommend a CPA who can advise on structure and tax treatment, including any 1031 exchange, and a real estate attorney to review the contract, title, goodwill, and leases.
Talk it through before you make an offer
I bring 25+ years in sales, negotiation and business strategy to commercial real estate across Central Florida. If you’re looking at an investment property in Orlando, Winter Park, or the surrounding counties, I’ll help you check the numbers, ask the right questions, and decide whether it fits your plan.
Related reading
- Selling a business with its real estate in Orlando
- How to analyze a rent roll
- How to evaluate a property for investment in Central Florida (a broader, non-commercial overview)
Mike Giordano Jr | MGG Team | Coldwell Banker Realty | 400 S Park Ave, Ste 210, Winter Park, FL 32789